Libby Klein I am slammed with ads on Facebook and Instagram for these outrageously expensive protein cookies from Maison Methodologie. They always look amazing and I want them. The first time I looked into buying them I thought for sure I was misunderstanding something. Like is that assortment for a dozen of each cookie? or a dozen total cookies. If you've checked them out you know exactly what I mean. So I confess. I finally broke down and bought them. They are good. They are smaller than I expected for the price. And I can tell you from working on a copycat recipe that a lot of the cost comes from high quality ingredients and the amount of protein powder necessary to get the cookies to meet the macros they say they have. Plus the packaging and the detail and of course the profit margin. And I personally love a variety pack of just about anything.
While all that is true, and they were a very nice treat, I still can't afford to eat a $12 cookie every day. And since I know how to bake, I have no business buying $12 cookies very often when I can just make them myself. No offence to Maison Methodologie. You better believe I'm waiting to see what the post Thanksgiving sale looks like!
So the cookie I decided to tackle was their Haunted Dubai for Halloween. I cannot guarantee that a side by side comparison would prove I have nailed this copycat because it's not one that I received in my order. But I did make a very good cookie that makes for a high protein snack or meal replacement.
I used President butter from France, Valrhona chocolate from France, Pistachio Paste from Sicily, Einkorn wheat, Black Cocoa from King Arthur and Levels Vanilla Bean Protein Powder.
I know the recipe isn't exactly the same because, Dubai chocolate has toasted coconut involved and I did not add that. You could though. Just toast a few tablespoon of coconut and add it on top of the pistachio. I also did not add any green food coloring to my pistachio because I prefer not to have colorings whenever possible. I used a very expensive Sicilian Pistachio spread, but you could substitute just white chocolate ganache with green food coloring if you're going for the look without the pistachio flavor and added expense.
In fact, if you make these for the kids for Halloween you can just make any chocolate-chocolate-chip cookie recipe you want and decorate them with the green tinted white chocolate and candy eyes. But if you're going for the high protein kick so you can have one of these as a meal replacement, I've got you covered with the whole recipe below, and the nutrition information and comparison is below that. Be sure to let me know in the comments what you think.
Haunted Dubai Monster Cookies
Maison Methodologie Copycat
Ingredients
2 sticks (1 cup) of French butter
¾ cup light brown sugar
¼ cup monk fruit with allulose
1½ cup Einkorn flour
1½ cup Vanilla Protein Powder
¼ cup black cocoa powder
½ tsp baking soda
½ tsp kosher salt
3 eggs
140 grams Valrhona milk chocolate (Either feves or chopped chocolate bars)
24 tsp (1/2 cup)
Sicilian Pistachio Spread
48 candy eyes
*If you have coconut, toast some and sprinkle it on top to make these a really nice Dubai Chocolate inspired Cookie.
Directions
Preheat your oven to 350°.
Combine Flour, Vanilla Protein Powder, Black Cocoa, baking soda, and salt in a separate bowl. Whisk to combine.
Put butter, brown sugar, and monk fruit in the bowl of your stand mixer. Beat until thick and creamy. Add Eggs and molasses to the sugar and butter. Beat to combine. Add in the dry ingredients and mix on low until the dough comes together.
Chop the chocolate if necessary. Add to the cookie dough. Mix well. Take the dough and form either 18 large balls or 24 medium sized balls with a chocolate piece on top. Flatten slightly.
Bake in a 350° oven for 10 minutes for 24 medium cookies, 12-14 minutes for 18 large cookies. Let cool on the pan.
Stir your pistachio paste until smooth. Drizzle lines of pistachio paste across the center of each cookie. Add two candy eyes in the middle of the pistachio paste.
I tried to make 70 gram cookies like the Maison Methodologie website says their cookies weigh, but they were way too big for me and came in at a whopping 400 calories. At 70 grams each, the recipe makes 15 cookies.
If you make 18 large sized cookies, they each have
330 calories / 19.5 g protein / 18g fat / 22g carbs.
If you make 24 Medium cookies, they each have
250 Calories / 14 g protein / 13 g fat / 17g carbs.
For comparison, the macros for the Maison Methodologie Brown Butter Milk Chocolate Cookies according to their website are
293 Calories / 15 g protein / 16 g fat / 23 g carbs.
Layla Virtue, a blue-haired, 30-something recovering alcoholic and former cop is trying to reinvent herself as a musician—between AA meetings, dodging eccentric neighbors at her trailer park, and reconnecting with her mysterious dad—in this unforgettable new mystery brimming with hilarity and heart.
Layla is taking her new life one day at a time from the Lake Pinecrest Trailer Park she now calls home. Being alone is how she likes it. Simple. Uncomplicated. Though try telling that to the group of local ladies who are in relentless pursuit of Layla as their new BFF, determined to make her join them for coffee and donuts.
After her first career ended in a literal explosion, Layla’s trying to eke out a living as a rock musician. It’s not easy competing against garage bands who work for tacos and create their music on a computer, while all she has is an electric guitar and leather-ish pants. But Layla isn’t in a position to turn down any gig. Which is why she’s at an 8-year-old’s birthday party, watching as Chuckles the Clown takes a bow under the balloon animals. No one expects it will be his last . . .
Who would want to kill a clown—and why? Layla and her unshakable posse are suddenly embroiled in the seedy underbelly of the upper-class world of second wives and trust fund kids, determined to uncover what magnetic hold a pudgy, balding clown had over women who seem to have everything they could ever want. Then again, Layla knows full well that people are rarely quite what they seem—herself included . . .

I had never heard of those cookies, but these are adorable and I'm sure they're super tasty!
ReplyDeleteThey are very tasty, but certainly geared toward people on a high protein diet.
DeleteI like your version better, less carbs. Thanks for the recipe Libby.
ReplyDeleteYou are very welcome! You can certainly make a healthier cookie than this, but I tried to get my macros as close to Maison Methodologie as possible.
DeleteLibby, I didn’t know about Maison Methodologie cookies, but I do know Dubai chocolate bars. They’re great and these sound pretty similar. No way I’d spend $12 on one cookie though. Yours sound much better!
ReplyDeleteThank you Ang. This Dubai chocolate bar seems to be all the rage right now. But 30 years ago when I wanted to put hot fudge on pistachio ice cream everyone thought I was crazy.
DeleteThank you for the Haunted Dubai Monster Cookies recipe! Delicious way to get the protein in a diet.
ReplyDelete2clowns at arkansas dot net
You are very welcome Kay!
DeleteTo be honest it wasn't until recently that I heard about Maison Methodologie cookies and almost choked when I saw the price, lol. Thanks for sharing your copycat Haunted Dubai Monster Cookies recipe! They look super cute for Halloween and sound so chocolaty and delicious!
ReplyDeleteSame. I messaged them several times thinking I misunderstood something. These are delicious, but then they're really just a regular cookie with protein powder swapped out for most of the flour. You could make any flavor this way.
DeleteHappy Halloween, Libby! I also never heard of Maison Methodologie and their Dubai cookies. If I had seen them and the price was attached, I would have whooshed right by them. No cookie is worth $12 in my humble opinion. I do so appreciate your going to all the trouble and effort...and expense...in creating your own version and then sharing the recipe and photos with us. They look like they would please any chocolover ! JOY! Luis at ole dot travel
ReplyDeleteThey are delicious, and perfect for the person who wants to get their protein numbers up.
DeleteMonk fruit and feves? Talk about exotic!
ReplyDeleteI've bought the feves many times whenever I make macarons. They are definitely pushing the price of the cookie up.
DeleteWhat makes them Dubai?
ReplyDeleteDubai chocolate is a bit of a fad right now. I've had one Dubai chocolate bar, and it was milk chocolate with a pistachio creme and toasted coconut. So when you see "Dubai chocolate" think of those three elements together. (except here where I left the coconut out)
DeleteWhere can I get Monk Fruit? The cookies look cute!
ReplyDeleteYou should be able to get Monk Fruit in any grocery store these days. But I live in a pretty metropolitan area so maybe I'm just spoiled. Both Thrive Market and Amazon would be good sources for online purchase if your local grocery store doesn't have the Monk fruit. Don't swap out ALL the sugar in a recipe with monk fruit though. You will not get the same consistency in your finished bake.
DeleteThanks for the recipe. Deborah
ReplyDeleteYou are very welcome Deborah.
DeleteThis is so cool, Libby. I've never heard of these cookies but yours look sensational and sound delicious. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much, Molly.
Delete