What's your favorite pie?
Leave a comment to enter our giveaway
drawing for 4 terrific cozy mysteries.
🍎🍎🍎
MADDIE DAY: I love pies so much. I make a world-famous (well, among my family and friends) apple pie with a towering homemade butter-based crust at least once every fall, plus pumpkin and pecan pies at Thanksgiving.
Plus, quiches are on our regular dinner rotation, made with an easy (and zero-fat) brown rice crust and often meatless. Back when my first Local Foods mystery came out in 2013, I was a guest here with a Spring Garlic Quiche recipe!
🍏🍏🍏
LESLIE KARST: I’m not a big fan of baking, as I find all that measuring and weighing of ingredients to be tedious. So much more fun to simply taste, add a handful of this or that, then taste again! But I do adore pies, the more buttery and flaky the crust the better. So one Christmas a few years back I set out to make a mince pie.
you know it's rich when the dollop of whipped cream cuts the fat
This was to be a “real” mince pie, like in the olden times—one made not simply with apples, raisin, and brown sugar such as we eat these days, but also with beef and suet (i.e., beef fat). It was a fair amount of work to prepare, but my, oh, my was it delicious! And rich. Probably the richest dessert I’ve ever eaten in my life, actually. But oh, so good! Perhaps I’ll post the recipe here at the Kitchen one of these days...
🍮🌿🍦
TINA KASHIAN: I enjoy cooking more than baking, but I recently baked an apple pie with my oldest daughter. We prepared crust from scratch and peeled and cut the apples together. We had a wonderful time chatting as we measured ingredients and rolled the crust. The kitchen smelled heavenly. Our pie may not look perfect, but it tasted great. Apple pie is a favorite in our house. We plan on baking again for Thanksgiving.
🍑🍒🍎
🍁🌰🍂
LUCY BURDETTE: Although I do prefer cakes to pies, pie features strongly in a couple of my books. A DEADLY FEAST has the only Thanksgiving backdrop and I did include a killer pumpkin pie that tastes of maple syrup and chai spice (mouth is watering!)And back in DEATH IN FOUR COURSES, Hayley made an amazing hot fudge pie that can be whipped up in no time and baked while you eat dinner.
And finally, THE KEY LIME CRIME should be served with a key lime pie since it's important to the story in so many ways! (The one in the photo is from Old Town Bakery.)
🍑🍇🍑
🍒🌰🍒
One February, my mother made two cherry pies for the high school carnival's cake and pie walk, part of the festivities before Lent started. She set them on the kitchen counter to cool, and a certain little girl climbed up on the counter and ate half the rim of one pie. That little girl did not get to go to the carnival that year. But she still adores cherry pie, especially the crust. And the classic Strawberry-Rhubarb (pictured). And Lemon Meringue. And -- oh, who am I fooling? While I'll always choose pecan over pumpkin at Thanksgiving, I just plain love pie.
🍁🍒🍂
VICKI DELANY: I’m a HUGE pie baker. I love making pies even more than eating them. My mom made great pies and I hope I’m following in her footsteps. I have, however, one daughter who doesn’t eat desserts and one who doesn’t like fruit pies (go figure!) so the opportunity to bake pies are limited. My favourite, if I had to choose, is blueberry. I also like savoury pies. I’m planning to try a new recipe for mushroom and butternut squash pie next week so I’ll let you know how it goes . In these pictures I’m assisting my son-in-law with two cherry pies. I was the pitter.
☕🍎☕
GIVEAWAY!
To be entered in this week's drawing,
join us in the comments.
What's your favorite pie?
Include your email address,
so we can contact the winner!
Comments Open through
Wednesday, November 10
>> MURDER AT THE LOBSTAH SHACK (ARC)
by Maddie Day
>> GINGERDEAD MAN by Maya Corrigan
>> HEATHER AND HOMICIDE by Molly MacRae
>> TREBLE AT THE JAM FEST by Leslie Budewitz
Comments Open through
Wednesday, November 10
🍂🍁🍂
I love pies! My favorite would be cherry! Dspinlexo at aol dot com
ReplyDeleteAt my request, my mom would make me a cherry pie instead of cake for every birthday when I was a kid. Miss them--and her.
DeleteI love almost all pies (except mince meat) especially those baked by my husband, who is a fabulous baker. My favourite, though, has to be pumpkin - when I grow my own pumpkins and make the filling from scratch. The filling taste is enough to overcome what's missing in my crust making skills!! ������
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment, Christopher. I agree that pie filling can redeem its crust. How lucky you are to have a husband who bakes!
DeleteApple pie with cheddar cheese.
ReplyDeleteTerry0743@aol.com
My all time favorite pie is pecan pie.
ReplyDelete3labsmom(at)gmail(dot)com
I love eating (and occasionally baking) pies.
ReplyDeleteMy fave pies are the ones made with summer fruits:
sour cherry, peach or Saskatoon berry pie.
grace dot koshida at gmail dot com
Thanks for your comment, Grace. Pies with fresh fruit filling can't be beat. ~Maya
DeleteIt's a tie, I love Lemon Meringue and Pumpkin Pie and usually have both on the holidays and have a small slice of each so that I don't have to decide. Thank you for this chance at your giveaway! pgenest57 at aol dot com
ReplyDeleteI love pies �� ��! My 2 absolute favorite are, of course, Apple pie heated with Ice Cream and Banana cream pie. There are others, but these are my fave. Thank you for the giveaway!!
ReplyDeletestrgth4yu(at)hotmail(dot)com
My favorite pie is strawberry rhubarb.
ReplyDeleteKitten143 (at) Verizon (dot) net
Strawberry and rhubarb make a great fruit combination, better than either fruit alone. Thanks for your comment! ~Maya
DeleteChristine, if you like rhubarb, you've got to try Rhubarb Custard Pie. So surprising and so good!
DeleteHappy Sunday. Thanks for sharing your favorite pies. This was fun. My favorite pies are any berry, apple, pumpkin and custard. My sister makes the best custard that I can eat, without all the sugar and crustless. She makes one just for me and my husband for Thanksgiving and one for Christmas. quilting dash lady at comcast dot net
ReplyDeleteFor me, it depends on the season most times. In the fall, nothing beats a good cinnamon infused apple pie with apples picked right off the tree or my Mom's Praline Pumpkin Pie. Winter makes me think of coconut cream pie because my Dad's birthday was December and that was always he's request. Spring I think about my Mom's fried banana pies which is a southern variation of the ones made from things like apple and cherry. Summer is for fresh picked peaches made into a delicious pie of which I have several recipes. That's one of the things I love about baking is the memories they bring back to the forefront of our minds.
ReplyDeleteFor an easy, but oh so scrumptious pie though my favorite is the Millionaire Pie. It's rich, has so many ingredients that I love on their own and everyone loves it as much as I do too.
MILLIONAIRE PIE
INGREDIENTS:
1 prepared graham cracker crust
1 cup sweetened flaked coconut
1 can (15.25oz) crushed pineapple, well drained
1 cup maraschino cherries , drained & chopped
1/2 cup chopped pecans
1 can Sweetened Condensed Milk (14 oz)
5 tablespoons lemon juice
1 tablespoon maraschino cherry juice
1 1/2 cups whipped topping (plus extra for garnish if desired)
DIRECTIONS:
In a large bowl, combine coconut, crushed pineapple, maraschino cherries, pecans, (Eagle Brand) Sweetened Condensed Milk, lemon juice and maraschino cherry juice.
Gently fold in whipped topping. Pour into crust.
Top with additional whipped topping and cherries if desired. Refrigerate 3 hours or overnight.
NOTES:
Do not skip or substitute the lemon juice or this pie will not set properly.
Thank you for the fabulous opportunity to win some amazing books! Shared and hoping to be the fortunate one selected.
2clowns at arkansas dot net
Thank you for the recipe, Kay! ~Maya
DeleteWe were just talking about Millionaire pie yesterday! Thank you so much for sharing the recipe!
DeleteI enjoy a good piece of pie and especially with a scoop of ice cream on top. One of my favorite pies is homemade coconut cream pie. My mother-in-law made one of the best.
ReplyDeleteFirst let me say all those pies sound wonderful. I have to make them all.
ReplyDeleteAs for me my favorite it is a tie between a Coconut Custard Pie or Pecan Pie.
Now I am thinking of others. Do we have to pick just one? (Or two in my case LOL)
ShawnStevensBooks(at)Gmail
(dot)com
My all time favorite is apple. Years ago a friends grandmother made lemon chiffon pie that was heavenly. It is still a favorite memory of my visit with them. egoehner(at)roadrunner(dot)com.
ReplyDeleteIsn't it wonderful how those memories of special dishes linger in our memories?
DeleteI love most fresh fruit pies, but my favorite is probably chocolate cream.
ReplyDeleteI have made some nice apple pies, especially in the last year, when I had so much time at home.
Not sure why my email does not show. It is auntbopp@yahoo.com
DeleteAlthough she claimed she did not enjoy cooking, my mother was a fabulous home cook. Her pie crusts was delicious, light, and flakey. I judge all pie crusts based on the ones she made. So I do not often eat pie away from home as most other standard pie crusts do not measure up to hers. There is a tie for my favorite pies both made by my mother: lemon meringue pie with flakey crust and meringue in beautiful peaks and lightly browned and her fabulous pecan pie also with her to die for home made pie crust. We had a small pear tree in the back yard, and she also made a great pear pie as well as a pear cobbler. How I would love to have a slice of her lemon or pecan pie today!
ReplyDeleteNancy
allibrary (at) aol (dot) com
Such wonderful memories, Nancy! The art of the pie crust is so worth cultivating.
DeleteFavorite is Cherry, but I love most so Fruit pies! I Assisi love Mince Meat, Pumpkin and Key Lime
ReplyDeleteMdlaugh1 (at) gmail (dot) com
conney.parkhurst@gmail.com. My favorite pie is cherry but I also like Key Lime Pie. Hoping to win one of the books. I really enjoy Mystery Lovers Kitchen.
ReplyDeletePumpkin pie is my favorite, although being from Indiana it should be Sugar Cream Pie. I will be having some of both this Christmas!
ReplyDeleteBeing from California, I've only read about Sugar Cream Pie, but it sounds amazing!! Must visit Indiana to try it (and your famous fried chicken, as well!).
DeletePie, yummy. Strawberry-rhubarb is my all time favorite but I love them all. Custard like my grandma used to make, banana cream, peach, pumpkin is actually at the bottom of the list. Thanks for the giveaway.
ReplyDeletesallycootie@gmail.com
Anything with custard or cream!
DeleteBlueberry is my favorite pie. cheetahthecat1986ATgmailDOTcom
ReplyDeleteGranny Kat here good Sunday morning I enjoy making and eating Bumble Berry pie there's a little of every local berry in it and a lot of the little 😋. Kat
ReplyDeleteMy absolute favorite is Key Lime pie! But won't turn down any other! lol
ReplyDeleteMy favourite pie was one my mom made- raisin pie with meringue on top.
ReplyDeletelhallson@shaw.ca
That sounds absolutely delish!
DeleteMy all time favorite is Key Lime - served "frozen" is best. I also like apple and sour cherry
ReplyDeleteI do love me a key lime pie--and frozen sounds fab!
DeleteLemon pie is my favorite of all. saubleb(at)gmail(dot)com
ReplyDeleteMy favorite pie is Chocolate Satin. It is a Chocolate Mousse pie. So good!
ReplyDeleteMy mother-in-law made a pie called Chocolate Silk. I wonder if it's similar to Chocolate Satin.
DeleteI love pie I must confess. Pre-made crusts do help so much. When I was first married 50 odd years ago I made lemon meringue lots as it was my husband's favorite and made my own crust too.We picked blueberries and peaches that I baked in pie and cobblers plus apples.Plan pumpkin and apple for holidays. Thanks for recipes and ideas.
ReplyDeleteI love pies! Chicken pot pie for a meal, strawberry or lemon meringue for dessert.
ReplyDeletekozo8989(at)hotmail(dot)com
My favorite is rhubarb, so I will definitely be trying Leslie's Rhubarb Custard Pie.
ReplyDeleteMy favorite pie is pumpkin pie.
ReplyDeletelindalou64(@)live(dot)com
Strawberry Rhubarb for its tartness and sweet flavor is delectable. elliotbencan(at)hotmail(dot)com
ReplyDeleteI love pies. I make my apple pie without a crust and with a streusel topping. My Mom always called it an English Apple Pie and it's really tasty.
ReplyDeletediannekc8(at)gmail(dot)com
My mother often made apple crisp, similar to your mom's apple pie without a crust and with streusel topping. ~Maya
DeleteI do love pumpkin, but I'd love to taste Edith's apple and Lucy's key lime . . . ;-)
ReplyDeleteI made a pumpkin, cheesecake, pecan wonder for a friend's Thanksgiving, using a prepared crust which had a not-easy-to-see paper on it. It was messy but still tasty, and he and his sons were kind.
My favorite pie is fresh strawberry pie, but only in June when I can pick the berries here in WI. Otherwise, whatever fruit is in season. Apple is always good, but especially this time of year. I also loved Maddie's Spring Garlic Quiche.
ReplyDeleteemmasmom69 AT gmail DOT com
Depends. When fresh Maine wild blueberries are available, it's raw blueberries with a lemon glaze in a pre-baked shell time. Big time!
ReplyDeleteOtherwise, chocolate cream, banana cream (for my husband), apple, peach,...
It's all (almost all) good.
libbydodd at comcast dot net
P.S. for all you apple pie lovers, my mother loved leftover apple pie for breakfast with a slab of sharp cheddar cheese.
DeleteChocolate Pecan Pie that my friend makes only for Christmas. It is beyond delicious. Thank you for this chance. areewekidding(at)yahoo(dot)com
ReplyDeleteWild blueberry pie is my favorite.
ReplyDeletejtcgc at yahoo dot com
Cherry pie! Dutch apple! Key lime! Chess pie! All good.
ReplyDeletepatdupuy@yahoo.com
So true. :-)
DeleteSo many great recipes! I don't know where to start. My favorite pie is my Mom's chocolate pie. My husband's favorite pie is apple pie. We really like all pies though! I've never mastered the art of making a pie crust so I buy pie crusts. lnchudej@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteMy favorite is lemon meringue!
ReplyDeleteJHolden955(at)gmail(dot)com
lemon meringue!
ReplyDeletemgshepherd2003@yahoo.ca
I enjoy making pies from scratch. My favorite is warm apple pie. I made one yesterday with a shortbread crust. I also make a pretty awesome cinnamon pie!
ReplyDeleteskforrest1957(at)gmail(dot)com
Thanks for commenting, Sharon. I've never heard of cinnamon pie, but since I love the spice and pie, the combo sounds delicious. ~Maya
DeleteI love coconut cream and blackberry pies. 😋
ReplyDeleteDenise
dlc1228@gmail.com
I love pecan pie. Thanks for the chance!
ReplyDeleteJess
Maceoindo(at)yahoo(dot)com
Strawberry rhubarb is my favorite! tWarner419@aol.com
ReplyDeleteMy favorite is lemon meringue. Thank you for the chance gogo2007@rocketmail.com
ReplyDeleteMy favorite is Dutch apple pie but I won't turn down most types of pie if offered. lkish77123 at gmail dot com
ReplyDeleteMy favorite pie is Key Lime Pie. It makes me dream of beaches and ocean breezes!
ReplyDeletemy favorite pie is a mixed berry pie! donnaep7@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteI love pie! I don't bake them but my favorite is apple. I recently tried an apple peach combination that could become my new favorite.
ReplyDeleteI loved my grandmother’s pineapple pie but I also like Japanese Fruit Pie.
ReplyDeletedtaeadkins&gmail.com
Deletedtaeadkins@gmail.com sorry typing issues today.🤷♀️
DeletePineapple pie is a new one to me
DeleteThis is a hard one as I love all pies. And I enjoy making/eating them! Strawberry rhubarb would have to be my top one.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the chance!!
jarjm1980(at)hotmail(dot)com
I love peanut butter pie! cherierj(at)yahoo(dot)com
ReplyDeleteLemon
ReplyDeleteI love a variety of pies, my favorites are probably my sister's apple & pumpkin that she bakes every Thanksgiving. My grandson has a Pi Day birthday so he gets pie instead of cake!
ReplyDeletejrycar at gmail dot com
Yeah for Pi day!
DeleteI like pecan pie. lindaherold999(at)gmail(dot)com
ReplyDeleteI love Pecan Pie. Thanks for the giveaway. jeanna_massman at hotmail.com
ReplyDeleteI love pie ( unfortunately can't eat it any more)... my favorites are coconut cream, pecan, pumpkin, and Dutch apple. Yvette at yscuny@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteI love cherry, pumpkin, Sweet potato, and chocolate!
ReplyDeletePumpkin, pecan, grape (Concords only!) or lemon with meringue.
ReplyDeleteI've never heard of grape pie, but since I really enjoy grapes, I'd love to try that pie. Thanks for you comment. ~Maya
DeleteI LOVE all kinds of pies and yes, fall and winter pies are great but summer peach pies and key lime are the favorites of my family. My favorite is French apple, with the crispy cinnamon topping. I always bake up pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving and for Christmas I make a pie that has eggs, smoked turkey and cheese that my grandma used to make. Pies are fun :)
ReplyDeleteSuch marvelous pies plus all are gorgeous. My grandma raised me,everything was from scratch. Apple's from our Apple orchard, big garden,grandpa had bushes of every berry imagined even concord grapes. Time for pies often my tummy was already filled with the filling. She was brilliant enough to make wee one's she called 'test pies' that we tied out with our silver tea as the Real pies baked. We should all have the grace of her generation. I have given my grangirls a set tea set and homemade aprons plus baking pan & cookie mix and cute pot holders. After they stayed with us and we did all of the the above💕 making memories, like your Wonderful recipes. Thank you ladies.
ReplyDeleteGkathgoldin@yahoo.com
I'm definitely Team Pie. My favorites are cherry and key lime.
ReplyDeletewskwared(at)yahoo(dot)com
The ones I loved best as a kid are still some of my favorites: cherry, lemon meringue and chocolate cream. For real decadence I love Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie. lola777_22 at hotmail dot com
ReplyDeleteI love pecan pie, with lemon meringue a close second! Thanks for the chance! ljbonkoski@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteLove my mom's sweet potato pie. Learning to make it this year. Thanks for the chance.
ReplyDeletejacolbie_riggins@yahoo.com
I love pie, both sweet and savory, but coconut cream pie is my favorite pie, even when it’s cold outside. Carter.karen@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteoh my I love my apple pie! But it has to be a la mode LOL.
ReplyDeleteMy favorite pie is coconut cream pie, but it can't just be any ol' coconut cream pie. There is a place we go to every year for vacation, and there is a deli/bakery that has the most amazing pies I've ever tasted. The first year hubby and I bought a mini pie cuz the full size is huge and we knew both the kids wouldn't like it so it would be the perfect size... Nope. Our son tried a bite and devoured the pie before we had a chance to enjoy it. Needless to say we buy two now to have throughout the week we stay there. Now I want pie, have to wait till Aug 2022. Thank you for the chance.
ReplyDeletelilyanngill56(at)Gmail(dot)com
Pie is the dish my family is most know for, so there are just too many good ones to choose from. I love my aunt's tomato pie as lunch in the summer, but my mom makes a chocolate cherry pie that is also amazing!
ReplyDeleteClaire.denning.11@gmail.com
You Brought Pie? My favorite words! I'm jumping in with my beloved Custard Pie! Made in a blender, baked to perfection, topped with freshly ground nutmeg. Mmmmm! Delish!
ReplyDeletePie is always good! My mother's chocolate meringue pie is a favorite, and I love a good sweet potato pie in the fall. bunkielisa at gmail dot com
ReplyDeleteOh my, such wonderful recipes! My absolute favorite is Pecan Pie. Being from Georgia, we had access to pecans at Grandma's farm.
ReplyDeleteMy favorite apple pie was from a restaurant in Atlanta, Aunt Fanny's Cabin. It had a kind of caramel sauce topping which I have tried unsuccessfully to duplicate for 63 years! I am now famous in my family for Key Lime Pie which I discovered after moving to Florida. The recipe is on Nellie & Joe's Key West Lime juice! Margaret mcm802@aol.com
I am listed as Unknown because I used my Aol address. I do not use my Google email address
DeleteThere was a restaurant where I used to be able (recipe change) get a black bottom pie which was a layer of chocolate rum pudding topped with a layer of vanilla pudding topped with meringue. annefitza at yahoo dot com
ReplyDeleteThere was a restaurant where I used to be able (recipe change) get a black bottom pie which was a layer of chocolate rum pudding topped with a layer of vanilla pudding topped with meringue. annefitza at yahoo dot com
ReplyDeleteCherry pie
ReplyDeleteApple or Peach pie are wonderful
ReplyDeleteKey lime pie is my favorite--I love citrus!!
ReplyDeletesmurphy(at)macados(dot)net
Blueberry pie �� ��
ReplyDeleteHeidiark@yahoo.com
Homemade key lime pie using the King Arthur Flour recipe!
ReplyDeleteLizafust@gmail.com
I like fruit pies best like apple, apple cranberry,and. Blackberry. Ale mode is good too.
ReplyDeletekazmimmmk@gmail.com
I love them all, but favorite is apple pie 🥧
ReplyDeleteemail: booksnpugsagmeil.con
DeleteI love pumpkin pie, Turtle cheesecake, pumpkin cheesecake (I'm thinking about you Olive Garden and your pumpkin cheese), pecan pie, jello pie...so many yummy pies
ReplyDeletebarbiefan@comcast.net
My favorite is lemon meringue.Gogo2007@rocketmail.com
ReplyDeleteHow can you pick just one? I think I gained ten pounds reading everyone's favorites! Right now, I think I would love a slice of chocolate pecan pie warmed with a bit of ice cream or a dollop of whipped cream! Mmm! sharonrizzo@hotmail.com
ReplyDeleteMy favorite pie is Pear Bourbon with a crumble top. My friend makes it and I buy two. Sometimes I give one away! Sometimes, I keep it. :) paprgrrl@gmail.com
ReplyDelete